Welcome to the Lake Nillahcootie Fishing Guide. Lake Nillahcootie was built in 1967 as a local water supply in northern Victoria. This system has a capacity of 40,400 megalitres and is situated on the Broken River, 36km south of Benalla, near popular townships such as Mansfield, Bonnie Doon, and Lake Eildon. The lake features two spillways, and water is regularly stored and released annually. The main spillway has a unique-shaped crest that can discharge 117,000 megalitres per day. Nillahcootie is an Indian term meaning ‘Blue House’. This system has been heavily stocked with Murray Cod and yellowbelly for a few years now and will continue to flousih as a great native fishery in years to come.
BECOME A FISHINGMAD MEMBER & UNLOCK ACCESS TO
Weekly Fishing Reports | Workshops | Giveaways | Podcasts | Competitions | Maps | GPS Marks | Rigging Tutorials | Sounder School | Exclusive Footage | Tackle Talks | Gear Guides | Kayak Club | Much More
Things to do at Lake Nillahcootie
Lake Nillahcootie is an excellent destination for fishing and Boating. There are boat ramp facilities that are popular in Spring and Summer by anglers targeting Golden Perch. There is an established car park and toilet blocks. This is a popular place for swimming and has on-site picnic facilities near the dam. Nearby townships of Mansfield and Benalla have petrol stations, accommodation and restaurants.
Fishing Lake Nillahcootie
At Lake Nillahcootie, you can target
- Golden perch ( Yellow Belly )
- Murray cod
- redfin
- carp
This is a brilliant location for catching golden perch ( yellowbelly ), redfin and cod. Well, back in the 1990s, there was an effort to stock the system with Murray Cod; those plans were somewhat unsuccessful. Again, in the early 2000s, VFA started stocking the lake with Golden Perch. Once the water level was stable, the stocking programs slowly started to succeed. Over the past 20 years, Lake Nillahcootie has received almost 250,000 stocked fish, mainly natives, with a tremendous volume of Golden Perch and Murray Cod. You can see below the recent stocking here in 2021 and 2022 alone.

Today, access to the lake is excellent for boats as it’s a prime location to fish with a kayak or small boat and has plenty of productive areas for land-based anglers. There isn’t much structure in the lake, so keep an active eye on your sounder as you move around schooling fish, especially yellowbelly and redfin, which can be caught here in good numbers primarily in Spring and Summer, especially on evenings. Redfin and carp can be caught in big numbers when the water conditions are right. In general, the fishing is excellent, although the vast majority of redfin caught are quite small.
One of the most effective ways to catch perch in Lake Nillahcootie is trolling lures such as lipless cranks, mid-diving hard body lures and vibes at the back of your boat or kayak. Electric motors work great for this, and the reduced noise will help increase catch rates. Generally, we are trolling with 2 rods out the back, motoring along between 2.5 and 3.5 kilometres. You can also catch plenty in the right conditions, drifting and tee bagging the same lures up and down slowly. Once you get some catches, you can choose to anchor and fish those isolated areas, as golden perch and redfin tend to school up in good numbers.
Fishing for land-based anglers is also very good, with many spots around the lake where you can pull up a chair and rod holders. Using simple baits such as yabbies and scrub worms will account for many redfin, golden perch and carp, especially during the warmer months. You will be kept busy with the large volume of carp that stay around the shallows.
Watch our detailed video guide on our top 10 redfin lures below
Lake Nillahcootie Fishing Gear Selection

Multiple target species are at this location, all requiring quite different setups. And even picking a setup for a specific species here can be tricky. When targeting yellowbelly, a light or medium baitcasting rod should be paired with a 150 baitcast reel, or, as we often prefer, targeting them with a 2-5kg spin rod paired with a 2500-size reel. When targeting redfin and trout, we recommend a 2-4 kg spin rod paired with a 2500 size reel. If bait fishing for multiple species such as carp, yellowbelly, and redfin, a 3-5kg spin rod paired with a 2500 reel would work great
Murray Cod here can grow over a meter. Targeting those giant fish with big lures requires much heavier setups to ensure you can handle the fish’s raw size and power and not break your rod tip when casting heavy lures. Cod lures can weigh anything from 20 grams to 200 grams. Generally, when targeting cod, ideally, a heavy baitcast combo around 6″6 in length and 8-15kg in class paired with a 150/200 baitcast reel spooled with 50lb braid. You can go a bit heavier here if you’re targeting huge fish with large lures or smaller if you’re casting smaller lures for smaller cod.
Recommended fishing lures for Lake Nillahcootie

- Gulp 3-inch minnow
- Small curtail and paddletail soft plastics
- stump jumpers
- Jackall TN50
- Soft Vibes and Blades
- Storm Gomoku 40mm surface popper
- Zerek fish trap
- Jackall transams
- Samaki vibelicious
- eco gear ZX40
Recommended baits at Lake Nillahcootie

At this location, we highly recommend the baits suggested below. There are several ways to present baits, including a running sinker rig, a paternoster rig, or a dropper rig. The rig and sinker choice will depend on the species you are targeting and the conditions, such as wind and tidal strength.
- Scrub worms
- Powerbait
- Yabbies
- Mudeye
- Live minnow
- Maggots
- Cheese cubes
Targeting Yellowbelly at Lake Nillahcootie

Yellow belly, AKA Golden Perch, is a beautiful freshwater fish in this system. With a rich food source, they can grow to thick and plump sizes. Good lure choices include curl tail soft plastics; the Gulp 3-inch grub minnow in black is a standout choice. Soft vibes like the Zerek fish trap, and Samaki vibelicious are great options. Lip-less crank-baits, such as Jackall TN50 and TN60, remain very popular, as do blades like the eco gear ZX40 with stinger hooks. Other favourites are the reliable stump jumpers and spinnerbaits. Soft plastics work best on a 1/8 or 1/4 jig head vertically jigged along structure. This technique works particularly well when using spotlock or tying your boat or kayak up against trees. Slowly work the soft plastic against the tree and add some noise to the action by tapping the butt of your rod or by hitting the jig head into the timber. This brings out the predatory nature of the yellowbelly. Take advantage of Livescope, down scan and side scan technologies on your sounder and spend some time moving between the structure to find the fish. Other lures will also work well in open water, being slow-rolled or trolled. Typically, we use a light to medium spin rod around 7 feet in length, 2-4 or 3-5 kilo class, paired with a 2000 or 2500 size reel and spooled with 8-12-pound braid and an equivalent fluorocarbon leader. Baitcaster rods and reels are a very popular choice when targeting yellowbelly. Good options include a 3-5 or 4-6 baitcaster with a 2000 baitcaster reel. When bait fishing, a 7-foot light rod paired with a 3000-size reel is used. Good bait rigs include a paternoster rig with a small sinker at the bottom or a running sinker rig with scrub worms or yabbies.
Targeting Murray Cod at Lake Nillahcootie

Murray Cod is Australia’s largest freshwater fish, which grows to impressive sizes. Murray Cod are ambush predators that love the cover of structure, so make sure you concentrate your efforts on any visible structure, including logs and submerged trees. They will also seek shelter in deeper holes and rock ledges. Murray Cod are most active in low light conditions, such as sunrise and sundown. A medium to heavy bait-caster rod is ideal when targeting cod. At this system, which has giant cod, we recommend a heavy baitcast combo around 6″6 in length and 8-15kg in class paired with a 150/200 baitcast reel spooled with 50lb braid. You can also fish lighter, which might be a stiff 6-foot rod in the 6-10 kilo class matched with a suitable size bait-caster reel spooled with a 20lb to 30lb braid and 30lb to 40lb leader. Good lure options for Murray Cod include hard body lures, surface lures, spinnerbaits, swimbaits, shads, lipless crankbaits, paddle tail and curtail soft plastics. If access is permitted, these should be worked slowly or trolled from your boat or kayak. Some terrific surface lures are on the market these days, including imitation mice, frogs, ducks, and snakes with realistic action that are fun to target cod with. Bait anglers can target Murray cod with live yabbies and worms.
Watch a detailed video of Al from FishingMad walking you through how to catch big Murray Cod.
Targeting Redfin at Lake Nillahcootie

We recommend targeting Redfin with a light spin outfit. This will make the experience more enjoyable and improve your catch rates. A 2-4 kilo fishing rod coupled with a 2000 or 2500 reel spooled with 4-8-pound braid and an equivalent fluorocarbon leader should be perfect. Redfin responds well to lures and soft plastics, so check our guide on the best lures for catching Redfin. When using soft plastics, we highly recommend curl tails, minnow imitations, and paddle tails in natural and bright colours. Rigged with a jig head that’s 1/8 through to 1/20 in weight. The most effective way to use these is to cast towards visible structure and slow roll the soft plastic with lifts and pauses for the retrieve. Shallow diving hard body lures, blades and vibes are also very effective in this system. So are traditional spinners and Tassie devils in bright colours. Metal spoons also play a role in allowing you to cast great distances and target the bigger reddies. Just remember, they are pretty heavy and very prone to snags in small inland systems like this one.
Lake Eppalock Lake Nillahcootie

We highly recommend you read our detailed guide on how to catch carp fishing around Victoria. Carp will actively take simple baits like worms, corn, bread, and maggots on a running sinker rig with a small sinker. Suspending baits from a float also works well, as do unweighted baits. You can target carp with hard-body lures and soft plastics; however, this is a complex technique that generally requires sight casting a nearby carp, casting towards them and working the lure of plastic slowly, hoping they will strike. It’s challenging but rewarding when you catch a carp using this method. Most anglers, however, will stick to targeting them with bait.
A 2-5 kilo rod coupled with a 3000 size reel is very suitable. You could even fish a little heavier if the system is known to hold huge ones up to a meter. I have caught some monster-size carp using a 2-4 kilo rod and 6-pound braid for fun. But I am prepared to lose some good fish in the process. We like to target carp at sundown, particularly in the warmer months. This is often when you see carp swimming along the edges or jumping out of the water around September-November, which is their spawning season. European carp must not be returned to the water. A simple yet effective fishing rig involves threading a small running sinker through the mainline, typically around 8 pounds, as shown in blue. Then, tie a medium swivel to the end, allowing the sinker to run up the mainline freely. Then, tie on the other end of the swivel 50cm of 8-pound fluorocarbon leader (the leader is shown in grey ). Finished with a hook. I generally use a size six bait keeper hook or a size 10 long shank, which is perfect for corn kernels or scrub worms; however, you can also use small treble style hooks, which is a better setup if you use bread.

If you’re getting snagged, you can also use a float rig. Attach a quill or bubble float to your mainline. Thread the line through and adjust the length using a size 6 bait keeper hook or size 10 long shank to keep your bait suspended at a good depth. Ideally, cast down the breeze, stopping the float from returning to you. If you’re not getting bites, adjust the line depth and, if necessary, add a splint shot to add weight.

Always carry your Victorian fishing license. FishingMad encourages ‘catch & release of all native species to help maintain the water quality within the lake; however, European Carp must not be returned. Access to the Lake foreshore is restricted as most of the land is privately leased. Camping is not permitted around the foreshore of the lake. Picnic and boating areas are open to the public from 8:00 am to sunset daily. Images of fish supplied by VFA and DEPI & Visit Victoria Website. All photos and videos shown on the Lake Nillahcootie Fishing Guide are Fishing Mad originals. Lake Nillahcootie Fishing Guide. If you believe this location guide is missing key information or requires corrections, please email our team at enquiries@fishingmad.com.au with specific details. Please also feel free to share any fishing pictures you have from this location with us. Thank you


